POLL: If Ford offers engine option (V6 and V8), which one would you pick?

Which engine would you choose in the 2017 raptor?


  • Total voters
    431

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Wilson

FRF Addict
Joined
Jan 27, 2012
Posts
26,211
Reaction score
10,315
Location
South Dakota
I owned mine for 11 years. That was not my experience. It was putting down 528 rwhp on the race gas tune when I got rid of it. I never put a dime in it that wasn't maintenance or mod related with the exception of a failed MAF. I think that was ~$300. I did all of my own work. God knows I would not have wanted to have to pay anyone else to work on it though. Bend over!!!

That being said. I saw plenty that were not taken care of and I would NEVER have owned. Vacuum/boost leaks, corroded connectors, injector failures (after ethanol mix) were the biggest issues. The VG30DETT and the rest of the drivetrain were rock solid. I never babied it and tracked it often.


Mishimota.jpg

Was it becose of using stabil with ethanol?
 

beachz

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2014
Posts
870
Reaction score
974
Location
Monument, CO
Was it becose of using stabil with ethanol?

I had larger NISMO injectors in the TT. They didn't mind then ethanol. I never had an issue with it.

For some reason the stock injectors were prone to failure. We also owned a normally aspirated 300ZX that my wife drove. We lost three injectors within about 8 months of the transition. I just pulled the plenum on the last one and changed them all. That is the only issue we ever had with the N/A.

RWM_3546-1.jpg

Theadjack complete... :) Sorry
 
OP
OP
S

skyscraper

FRF Addict
Joined
Sep 3, 2013
Posts
1,447
Reaction score
619
This poll is pretty stupid. It's like asking which is better....$35 or $50? Well apples to apples, $50 is of course more desired than $35. Of course there's a few outliers that will have some round about wack ball rationale of "well maybe $35 is better because I'll have to claim less taxes on miscellaneous income so maybe in the end the $35 will net me greater than $50", and there you have your 2 in 100 voting for $35 over $50.

Apples to apples an ecoboost 3.5 V6 vs an ecoboost 5.0 V8, in a gluttenous truck like a Raptor, pretty much everyone's going to choose the faster apple. If this were a regular f150 poll I'd expect different results as some people would be more inclined to want to save $1k on sticker, or get an extra 2 mpg at the sacrifice of 50-100 hp, but for a Raptor crowd, I could have called these poll results before it was even posted.

You want an interesting poll, make it 3.5 Ecoboost V6 vs. N/A V8. Then it's not "which is better $35 or $50", it's "which is better, $40 cash or $40 in gold".

Between a V6 TT and a V8 TT, I of course picked V8 TT. But now between a V6 TT and a V8 N/A......I'd go V6 TT in a heartbeat.






The 5.4 was on it's death bed before the 6.2 even hit the option sheet. It didn't die off because lack of interest. It died off because it was dead before the 6.2 even hit the option sheet. But that's the same kind of question as this poll. Would you prefer a 5.4 N/A V8 or a 6.2 N/A V8....a derrrr the one with more power and pretty much same fuel economy. Same question for V6 TT vs V8 TT.

BUT, just offering a V6 TT and no other options won't be the death of the Raptor. Ecoboost sales used to be 40% of all f150 engine choices, and V6 sales in total over 60%. I bet that number has risen even further since a few years ago. The Raptor is more about it's offroad capability, appearance, suspension, etc. than the engine under the hood. Very very very few guys are out there drag racing them, and the 3.5 EB can easily mop the floor with a 5.4 Raptor, and is right on par with the performance of the 6.2, and has already been stated to make MORE power than the 6.2, so if they're INCREASING the performance of the Gen 2, how is that the death of the Raptor by making it faster? Yes the exhaust note isn't the world's best, but that isn't going to destroy the sales.



That is a terrible analogy. They only offer ONE engine in the GT500 and ONE engine in the GT350/GT350R, which are the mustang equivalents of a Raptor in terms of being the specialty model of that vehicle line. I'm not saying it's impossible, but I'm saying there's no real rationale for them to offer engine choices in the Raptor just because they offer engine choices in a regular mustang. Typically their high performance/specialty line of vehicles they don't offer engine choices.

Gen 1 & Gen 2 Lightnings offered no engine choices
Gen 1 & Gen 2 Harley trucks offered no engine choices
GT500's offered no engine choices
GT350/GT350R's offer no engine choices
03-04 Cobras offered no engine choices
Boss Mustangs offered no engine choices
etc. etc. etc.

The only reason the 2010 Raptor offered an engine choice for a short period of time was the 6.2 wasn't ready for the release and the outdated 5.4 was available. Once the 6.2 was ready they kept the 5.4 around just so they could still get the trucks out the door as 6.2 production ramped up. Once 6.2's were in full swing the 5.4 was off the table.
Wow, the butthurt is strong with you. Not sure why?

it's a poll, you click one, or the other. Then pop a midol.

Or were you one of the v6 nut huggers that isn't too happy with the outcome?
 

beachz

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2014
Posts
870
Reaction score
974
Location
Monument, CO
^^^ I had one of those when I was younger. The penicillin knocked it right out though.
 
Last edited:

jchilcoat15

Member
Joined
May 9, 2014
Posts
27
Reaction score
4
honestly, the only thing that suffers from a TTV6 is the exhaust note. Most of your arguements do not make sense if you take "V8 or V6" verbage out. Of course we would take the V8 TT over the V6 TT, because we all assume it would be the baddest engine you could stick in one. lets face it, if we wanted second best we would have just bought any other half ton truck. If the poll read "Which engine would you choose for your next raptor, 411HP engine or the 450HP engine?"... if you want more, why not choose the engine with more upside?

Back to the poll, I would rather have a V8TT because there would be no sacrifice, but 6.2L vs 3.5L with a bulletproof block and the ability to crank up the boost and make tons of horsepower.. mehh.. the "tiny" v6 doesn't sound so bad.
 

Craigy

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2015
Posts
374
Reaction score
192
Yeah the $35 vs $50, or the 411 horse vs 450 horsepower questions are pretty much what this thread is about (although I suspect the 3.5TT is going to have 450-500+ horsepower, not a paltry 411). Of course you're going to pick the bigger one.

If I was shopping a regular F150 I'd choose the turbo 6 everytime. I don't care about a lot of power for putting around town. But in a Raptor... of course you want more power.

I suppose if we had more info it could be a more telling poll, such as (and I'm just making up numbers here):

1) Standard V6 Turbo, 500 horsepower, 16 mpg, 600 lbs, OR

2) Option V8 Turbo, 550 horsepower, 12 mpg, 850 lbs, $4,995 added cost.

In that case I might save my pennies and go with the V6.
 
Top